Reader's Digest

Travel, Health, Auto, Food, Home & DIY

  • Home
  • Travel
    • Travel Our Canada
    • Travel The World
    • Travel Tips
  • Health
    • Beauty
    • Conditions
    • Fitness
    • Healthy Living
    • Relationships
    • Weight Loss
  • Home & Garden
    • Best Tips
    • Cleaning & Organizing
    • Gardening
    • Home Improvement
    • Money
    • Pets
  • Food
    • Cooking Tips
    • Diet & Healthy Food
    • Recipes
  • Auto
    • Accessories
    • Buying Guide
    • Dream Cars
    • Maintenance
    • Road Trips
  • Contests
    • Monthly payout
  • Games
  • Magazine
    • Features
    • In This Issue
    • Reader’s Digest International
  • Trusted Brands
    • About The Study
    • Brand Showcase
    • 2018 Winners
  • Subscribe
    • Gift Subscriptions
    • Digital Editions
    • Customer Care
Home / Magazine / Features / The $273 Billion Question: Enbridge and the Northern Gateway Controversy /

The $273 Billion Question: Enbridge and the Northern Gateway Controversy

The Harper government wants to supercharge the
 Canadian economy by allowing over 200 tankers a year through the waters off British Columbia. Detractors of the so-called Northern Gateway insist a single oil spill is all it would take to destroy one of the world's most diverse natural environments. Is the payoff worth the risk? 

By Arno Kopecky

View as list
6 of 9
‹
›

Photo: Ilja Herb

Up we go through Seaforth Channel, the ocean’s swell rising as we enter Milbanke Sound, on the exposed outer edge of the Inside Passage. Soon Caamaño Sound opens up ahead, a circular hub of ocean from which channels jut out like spokes on a wheel. It’s the tide sloshing in and out of these inlets that creates the currents and whirlpools for which this zone is infamous. Still, if the weather was always as fair as we have it this summer, tankers might indeed be a viable option. 

A little further north, past Gil Island, we enter Douglas Channel. Eighty-three kilometres long, 3.5 kilometres wide, over 300 metres deep-this is the portion of the proposed route Enbridge depicts on its website. It’s the one relatively straight and simple part of the path, and it leads to Kitimat.

Born in the 1950s as a workers’ camp for Alcan-then one of the 
largest aluminum plants in the world-Kitimat slipped into a malaise when the town’s methanol plant closed in 2006, with the pulp-and-paper mill following four years later.

Today, Kitimat is resurgent. In 2007, Alcan was bought by Rio Tinto, which plans to ramp up production; more significantly, liquid-natural-gas production is booming throughout northern British Columbia and Alberta, and a number of corporations are eyeing Kitimat as the ideal port from which to ship their products. Workers are now flooding back to the town, and city council has declared itself officially neutral on the subject of the Northern Gateway. Mayor Joanne Monaghan has even discouraged councillors from speaking to journalists about it.

Phil Germuth is a mechanic and first-term Kitimat councillor whose frustration has led him to defy his mayor’s wishes. Forty-six with a chestnut goatee and hands that are permanently oil-stained, Germuth loves machines, loves industry, loves to work. “When I first heard about the Northern Gateway, I thought, Hey, great! Jobs! Money! But when you educate yourself about it, you realize, holy crap, this isn’t such a good deal for 50 jobs.” Fifty-two jobs, actually-that’s the number Enbridge has promised Kitimat, about the same number of people a single, large B.C. ferry would employ. Nationally, once construction is finished, Enbridge expects the pipeline will lead to no more than 269 full-time positions.

“I hate being neutral, because it means you’re neutralized,” says Germuth. “We’ve got more to lose than any other community-no one else is at risk of both a pipeline spill and a tanker spill.” In fact, Kitimat may soon be a hive of increased tanker traffic. Three liquid-natural-gas projects are being considered for the town, which could add three times as many tankers to the Northern Gateway route. DNV’s models for calculating the odds of a coastal accident don’t consider this addition.

Humpack whales feed on herring and krill in Bishop Bay, south of Kitimat.

Kitimat is full of people who feel the way Germuth does. There’s Murray Minchin, a local postman, who overcame a debilitating stutter to deliver a flawless testimony at the public hearings into the Northern Gateway. There’s Manny Arruda, an emergency-response team leader at Rio Tinto Alcan, who testified at the same hearings about the difficulties of dealing with emergencies in Kitimat’s harsh climate. There’s Kelly Marsh, Kitimat’s lean and boy-faced chief millwright who, with the help of a mathematician, believes he has caught a flaw in Enbridge’s risk analysis. When Riki Ott, a marine toxicologist from Valdez and international specialist in community responses to oil spills, delivers a talk at the Riverlodge Recreation Centre, the room is packed to capacity.

“I pushed council to have a survey done to know where Kitimat citizens truly stand,” says Germuth, “but they shot the motion down. I’d estimate this town is about 70/30 against the proposal. Everyone but our council has caught on that we have everything to lose, and nothing to gain.”

Next: The Northern Gateway’s massive
economic and ecologic impacts
.

Filed Under: Features

More From Reader’s Digest

  • This Is Why We Wear Wedding Rings on the Fourth FingerThis Is Why We Wear Wedding Rings on the Fourth Finger Ancient cultures had a sweet reasoning behind it. Posted in Features
  • What To Do When You Accidentally Fill Your Gas Tank with Diesel FuelWhat To Do When You Accidentally Fill Your Gas Tank with Diesel Fuel Gasoline in a diesel tank or diesel in a gasoline tank; either way it's not great news. Here are step-by-step instructions on how to deal with using the wrong fuel. Posted in Maintenance
  • Sandpaper DiscsSandpaper Discs Convert an electric hand drill into a sander. Posted in Home Improvement

Watch This

subscribe to reader’s digest

Get Today’s Best Deal!

Subscribe for a chance to win a $40,000 car!

  • Subscribe
  • Give a Gift
  • Digital Editions
Win a Car!

TRAVEL OUR CANADA

Take a Peek at This Canadian’s Impressive Antique Collection!

Mimico: The Fascinating History Behind One of Toronto’s Oldest Neighbourhoods

Remember Them: Jack Mitchinson

Special Features

  • sweeps-contest1

    Free Online Games

    Home to some of the most popular online games. They're fun, FREE, and totally addictive!

Connect with us

  • Email the editors
  • Submit a joke
  • In this issue

Contests

Monthly Payout

Win this month’s $1,000 cash prize!

Best Health Contests

Enter for your chance to win amazing prizes courtesy of Best Health

Share Your Snaps & Stories

Our Canada’s Theme Pics

Capture our theme of the month with your camera, and submit your shots.

  • In This Issue
  • Trusted Brands
  • Monthly Payout
  • Email the Editors
  • Submit a Joke
  • Email Communications
    • Sign Up
    • Unsubscribe
    • Manage
  • Magazines
    • Subscribe
    • Give a gift
    • Digital Edition
  • About Us
    • Privacy Policy
    • Terms of Use
    • Site Map
  • Contact Us
    • Advertise with us
    • Customer care
    • Sweepstakes
  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Pinterest
  • RSS
  • Twitter

Show Full Site

© 2018, The Reader's Digest Association (Canada) ULC - All rights reserved.

Please support this website by adding us to your whitelist in your ad blocker. Ads are what helps us bring you premium content! Thank you!